Tax Tips For Horse Business Disruptions in the Thoroughbred Industry

It is truthful to say that the previous few years have thrown up some huge challenges to anybody making an attempt to run a major manufacturing enterprise in regional Australia.

These challenges transcend monetary and financial upheavals such because the GFC, the stronger greenback and fixed volatility on international share markets. What I am speaking about are the dreaded “pure disasters” that periodically disrupt the companies of major producers, e.g. viruses, droughts, floods and bushfires.

It isn’t well-known that our tax legal guidelines include concessions that assist victims of those disruptions to manage financially by means of these tough intervals. It makes the job of an Accountant that little bit extra rewarding once we can move on and apply these concessions, too.

This text will define and talk about the concessions and some tax suggestions that I contemplate most related for horse homeowners and breeders caught up in these circumstances. Even if you cannot use them when making ready your 2011 tax return, I am hoping you may inform a buddy or two who wants some welcome excellent news in any case that nature has thrown as much as her or him lately.

1. Insurance coverage Recoveries for lack of livestock may be unfold over 5 years

If a taxation breeder receives an insurance coverage restoration for a lack of ”dwell inventory” or for a lack of bushes by fireplace, the tax act supplies the breeder with an election to unfold the evaluation of that revenue over 5 years. Nevertheless, the election is on the market provided that the related dwell inventory or bushes are held as property of a ”major manufacturing enterprise”.

N.B. This concession isn’t accessible to those that conduct a “stand-alone” racing exercise, with none related breeding.


Peter has his breeding property in Toowoomba and misplaced his prized broodmare within the current QLD floods.

The mare was insured for $200,000 and these proceeds had been duly acquired in March 2011. Peter’s cash-flow has been severely affected by the floods and he has little urge for food for paying tax on this revenue till he can get some yearlings to the gross sales within the subsequent few years.

To minimize the tax impression, Peter elects to unfold his insurance coverage restoration over 5 years, i.e. $200,000/5 yrs = $40,000 p.a. Accordingly, $40,000 was returned in FY 2011 and in every of the following 4 tax years.

2. Insurance coverage acquired re destruction of a constructing is handled as capital proceeds

Many enterprise associated buildings had been been destroyed on account of the current floods, bushfires and so forth.

The insurance coverage recovered on account of these occurrences are usually not returned as revenue within the yr acquired, as an alternative they’re handled because the capital proceeds on the disposal of those property.

The place an asset, or a part of an asset is misplaced or destroyed, any proceeds acquired by a taxpayer beneath an insurance coverage coverage in respect of the loss or destruction are taken to be quantities of cash acquired “on account of or in respect of” the disposal of the asset or a part of that asset. N.B. If an asset, or a part of an asset was acquired earlier than 20 September 1985, no a part of the proceeds acquired in relation to that asset or a part of that asset, could be topic to Capital Positive factors Tax (CGT).

Equally, the place a motorized vehicle is misplaced or destroyed, any insurance coverage restoration shall be consideration in respect of the disposal of that motorized vehicle, and so not topic to CGT.


A breeding firm acquires possession of a newly constructed constructing on 1 July 1986.

The associated fee base of the constructing is $10 million and the constructing is handled as a separate asset for CGT functions.

The constructing was subsequently destroyed by fireplace and the breeder lodged a declare beneath an insurance coverage coverage. On the time of acquisition, the taxpayer entered into an insurance coverage settlement that may cowl the taxpayer for the alternative price of the constructing. The alternative price at date of destruction is $18 million.

The insurance coverage payout of $18 million is taken to be the consideration on disposal of the constructing and, thus, isn’t 100% assessable within the yr acquired.

“Roll-over aid” beneath part the CGT act could also be accessible the place a alternative asset is acquired with the insurance coverage proceeds, i.e. the CGT price base of the alternative asset is lowered by the revenue on disposal of the constructing. Within the above situation, the revenue could be $eight million ($18 million insurance coverage proceeds much less $10 million price base)

three. Insurance coverage acquired for property which are a part of a “Small Enterprise Depreciation Pool”

Many smaller breeders declare depreciation utilizing the small enterprise depreciation pool.

For the document, a Small Enterprise Entity (SBE) is a tax enterprise with typically lower than $2m aggregated turnover p.a.

If within the occasion of insurance coverage acquired for the destruction of property, word:


    • The pool steadiness is lowered by the extent of insurance coverage acquired. Thus a revenue or loss on the objects destroyed needn’t be made when the insurance coverage is acquired; and


  • If the sum of the insurance coverage acquired of property disposed of in the course of the revenue yr exceeds the pool closing steadiness for the yr, the surplus is topic to taxation.



Janet the breeder misplaced beneficial sheds within the 2009 VIC bushfires.

The closing depreciation pool steadiness of her enterprise at 30 June 2009, was $12,500. Insurance coverage acquired for her sheds was $30,000. Accordingly, $17,500 ($30,000 much less $12,500) is taxable revenue to the enterprise within the FY 2009.

four. Belongings topic to “Roll-Over Aid” on account of destruction

As famous above in a CGT context, “Roll-over aid” happens the place earnings on disposal of property, e.g. the place insurance coverage proceeds exceed the written-down worth of asset, may be deferred. In relation to a enterprise asset, that is the place the revenue is offset towards the price of the alternative asset, as an alternative of being declared as revenue instantly.

In brief, sure, a breeder is ready to get hold of roll-over aid for an asset which was involuntarily destroyed by fireplace, flood and so forth. offered the next situations are glad:


  • The asset was not a pooled asset beneath the “Small Enterprise Entity” (SBE) regime or as a part of a low-value pool for non-SBE taxpayers; and
  • The taxpayer acquires a alternative asset throughout the required occasions



Large Breeder Pty Ltd, who doesn’t qualify as a “Small Enterprise Entity”, had a float destroyed within the Victorian floods of 2011.

Insurance coverage proceeds acquired in FY 2011 was $20,000, the written-down worth of the float at time of destruction was $5,000, thus a revenue on disposal of $15,000 was realised.

A alternative float was acquired for $30,000, inside solely three months of the occasion, effectively throughout the 12 month required time-frame, which commences on 30 June 2011.

As an alternative of Large Breeder having to declare the $15,000 as a revenue in FY 2011, what it does as an alternative is to scale back the fee base of the brand new depreciable asset to $15,000 ($30,000 price much less $15,000 revenue on the destroyed asset).

5. Belongings that may be written-off instantly

In lots of cases, enterprise plant and gear isn’t insured and no proceeds are acquired.

The place this happens, the tax “written-down” worth of the asset may be instantly written-off, this being a direct deduction within the tax yr this happens.

Nevertheless, it ought to be famous that solely a “non-SBE” can make the most of this concession as they aren’t be eligible to make use of “pooling” for his or her enterprise property.


Large Breeder Pty Ltd chooses to not insure any of its “on-farm” motor bikes.

All of those bikes had been “written-off” as unrecoverable after the VIC floods.

The tax written-down worth of its bikes on the date of destruction was $25,000. As no insurance coverage was acquired, a direct $25,000 deduction may be claimed for these property in that tax yr.

6. “Lack of revenue” insurance coverage is assessable to the breeder

The place insurance coverage funds are acquired to switch misplaced revenue, the proceeds are assessable to the breeder (e.g. enterprise interruption insurance coverage which typically supplies money stream till enterprise earnings attain what they had been earlier than the hearth. flood and so forth.).

7. Coping with the destruction of buying and selling inventory

a) Can a horse be written-off if no proceeds acquired?

A breeder is entitled to assert a deduction for the price of buying and selling inventory destroyed.

The deduction is obtained through the motion within the opening and shutting inventory provision.

b) Tax earnings from “compelled” disposal of inventory

Below the tax act, the place a major manufacturing enterprise is compelled to eliminate or destroy livestock, the breeder could also be entitled to concessional remedy in relation to any ensuing tax revenue, as follows:

  • unfold the tax earnings over 5 revenue yr; or
  • defer the tax revenue and offset it towards the price of alternative inventory over the next 5 revenue years.

This aid pertains to the compelled sale of livestock, and differs to the aid re spreading insurance coverage recoveries over 5 years, which pertains to the demise of livestock.

Nevertheless, this election is not going to be accessible the place the enterprise is offered following the pure catastrophe.

Instance – spreading the tax revenue

Breedco’s yearlings should be destroyed due to the current Hendra virus.

The insurance coverage proceeds of the compelled disposal are $250,000 and the tax revenue is $150,000. Breedco elects to unfold the tax revenue over 5 years. Breedco’s assessable revenue within the disposal yr contains an quantity of $130,000 in respect of the disposal. This quantity is arrived at by decreasing the proceeds of $250,000 by the tax revenue of $150,000 and including an quantity of $30,000 (i.e. 20% of the tax revenue of $150,000). For every of the 4 revenue years following the disposal yr, Breedco should embrace an quantity of $30,000 in its assessable revenue.

c) Closing inventory worth methodology may be altered

The golden rule of inventory accounting is that opening inventory ought to at all times equal closing inventory and nothing has modified on this regard.

Nevertheless, this doesn’t cease a breeder from altering the yr finish accounting inventory valuation methodology.

As an example, if market promoting worth has been used prior to now, this may be altered to make use of both the particular “write-off” or “price” closing inventory valuation strategies. This technique would assist immensely in decreasing taxable revenue in a selected tax yr, one thing that may be most welcome when you’ve been a sufferer of a pure catastrophe.


Stockco was severely affected by a brand new outbreak of EI virus that swept by means of the Hunter Valley, resulting in a lot of its prized yearlings being withdrawn from the 2012 Easter gross sales. Nevertheless, good cash was made on foals offered on the earlier Magic Tens of millions QLD gross sales. Tax revenue for the yr is $350,000.

With out the cash-flow from the Easter gross sales, Stockco requires choices to scale back its tax revenue for FY 2012. Martin the accountant finds that lots of the mares have been valued @ market worth as at 30 June 2011. By valuing these mares @ price as at 30 June 2012, the closing inventory worth of the mares is lowered by $150,000 and tax revenue can be lowered by this quantity to $200,000 ($350,000 much less $150,000).

eight. Points re withdrawing funds from a Farm Administration Deposit (FMD)

The FMD provisions are contained within the tax act and broadly allow an eligible taxpayer to defer the revenue tax on taxable major manufacturing (breeding) revenue from the revenue yr by which a FMD deposit is made (i.e. a deduction is on the market for such a deposit) till the FMD deposit is repaid (i.e. this quantity is included in taxable revenue within the yr of withdrawal).

Nevertheless, a FMD deposit (or half thereof) loses its standing as a FMD the place it’s withdrawn inside 12 months of the deposit date. In these circumstances, a partial withdrawal of an FMD signifies that solely the residual deposit quantity qualifies as an FMD, offered the remaining quantity is $1,000 or extra and offered that it stays within the account for at the least 12 months.

The implication for a FMD withdrawn inside 12 months is the no deduction is on the market for the deposit (and taxpayers might want to request an amended evaluation the place this rule results a deduction claimed within the prior revenue yr).

TAX TIP – Farm Administration Deposits withdrawn in distinctive circumstances

Nevertheless, as an exception to this, a deposit retains it standing as an FMD even whether it is withdrawn inside 12 months the place the taxpayer is in an space the Minister Of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry has declared an “distinctive circumstances”‘ space. On this regard, FMD deposit holders have till three months after the yr of revenue of the withdrawal to acquire an “distinctive circumstances”‘ certificates from the related state authority.

For extra data: Tax software partnerships

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *